Preview: United v Aston Villa

March 29, 2014 Tags: , Matches 3 comments
featured image

These are increasingly desperate times for David Moyes. It is not just that the Scot has presided over 13 defeats in all competitions this season as Manchester United’s campaign disintegrated, but the abject manner in which they have come. None more so than United’s defeat to crosstown rivals Manchester City on Tuesday night, which was as miserable as any in the derby – at least in living memory.

Little wonder the pressure is beginning to tell on the former Everton coach, who is desperately clinging on to the last vestiges of neither a job he is qualified to do, nor – it would appear – suitably equipped to undertake.

Fear, in Moyes circumstances, is perhaps understandable. It has been a campaign unravelling before the manager’s eyes and, with players disgruntled and fans revolting, now totally out of the Scot’s control. Yet, there is also something truly pathetic in the manager’s repeated pleas for time and hackneyed excuses for failure. It is the poise of a man neither comfortable in the job, nor demonstrating the aptitude for growth.

And yet Moyes still has the capacity to surprise when sinking to new public relations depths. In the past month alone the Scot suggested United was an underdog in the recent fixture against Liverpool, and then he expressed an “aspiration” that the Reds might reached City’s level.

Neither opinion – whether honest in conception or otherwise – should ever been raised by an incumbent United manager.

Still, there is something so completely off-piste in Moyes’ comments on Friday, suggesting former manager Sir Alex Ferguson would also have struggled this season that the new man has shocked once again.

“If Sir Alex was here it would be difficult for him as well, and I’m sure he’d be aware of it,” said Moyes.

“It could have been the case no matter what this season. But it has been so un-Man United, which is why we have to look to continue a policy of building, improving, getting better. I think people are aware there’s a squad that is a bit more ageing, so I think it would have been a tough season for probably whoever was in charge of Manchester United this year.”

It is a badly misconceived notion; that United, under Ferguson, would have slipped from an 11-point Premier League margin of victory to the lowest points total in a quarter century. No matter how old the squad.

With that Moyes also issued the now standard weekly supplicate for time, reinforcing the party line that the new man is simply on a long-term journey of transformation to the post-Ferguson era. That somehow failure this season was inevitable – understandable even – given the meager resources available and ill luck procured.

Moreover, promises Moyes, while it has been a season of poor harvest, there will be jam tomorrow. Just stick with the Scot as he rids the club of the bad ingredients that are an inhibitor to success.

“It’s a long journey here and this is only the start of it,” said Moyes. “You work hard to get here in the first place but I’ve got to say I’m more driven to succeed than ever because I want the team to turn around.

“We’ve got a great club, which gives you the chance to do that because of the people we can attract and the players we can attract to the club. But it’s just going to take a little bit of time to get it sorted.

“There’s a rebuilding plan underway and anybody who has an understanding of the game understands that will happen.”

Results matter though and performances, whatever the rebuilding promised in the summer, have been so wretched to date as to render Moyes’ analysis redundant. The Scot was left with an ageing squad, and far too much filler, but there are some coaches – Ferguson included – with the uncanny ability to extract more than the sum of ample parts.

Or in other words, United’s is comfortably a top four squad that achieved even more last season; the difference in performance level is largely the responsibility of the man now in charge.

So to the weekend and Aston Villa’s visit to Old Trafford – a venue in which United has already lost seven times this season.

Manchester United v Aston Villa, Premier League, Old Trafford, 12.45pm, 29 March 2014On the field Moyes will select a team to face Villa in Saturday’s lunchtime kick-off mindful both of United’s performance against City, and the Champions League quarter-final with Bayern Munich to come.

Captain Nemanja Vidic returns after a two-game suspension, although Chris Smalling, Jonny Evans and Robin van Persie remain on the sidelines with injury. Moyes could rest Wayne Rooney even if he has been reluctant to do so in the campaign to date.

So few United’s stars impressed against City that Moyes may be tempted to make wholesale changes on Saturday, although supporter unrest will surely reach a tipping point if United lose at home once again. It is a dichotomy of prioritisation that Moyes is ill-equipped to make.

After all, Moyes has bought time with positive results against mediocre opposition this season: Arsenal remains the only side in the Premier League’s top nine to have succumbed to United this season. And yet few expect anything other than heavy defeat to Bayern.

Indeed, there are few teams that define mediocre better than Villa; a side too good to go down, and yet nowhere near a threat to the country’s leading clubs.

Still, it is also at Old Trafford where United has struggled most this season, reflected in the points tally – just 18 from 15 home matches, which is less than 14th-placed Norwich City.

It is a weakness that Villa can exploit despite Paul Lambert’s side sinking to a humiliating home defeat against Stoke City last weekend. Lambert believes that United’s poor campaign is a “major disaster” that will play into the visitors’ hands.

“We have to use that to try and keep the crowd quiet,” said Lambert

“When you have a big following with expectancy levels and you don’t perform it can happen. Every club has down time at some point. I think what has happened to United is they lost a really successful boss. Somebody had to do the job. But there is a generation of their fans who haven’t been used to losing.”

Meanwhile, Lambert will be without Karim El Ahmadi for the journey north, although Andreas Weimann is available despite being substituted with injury in last weekend’s defeat to Stoke.

Still, whatever United’s form – even at home – anything less than comfortable victory against the Midlanders could be near terminally fatal for the United boss. In the circumstances, victory – almost any victory – must be found if supporter unrest is not to gather momentum. It is, after all, very much what a Ferguson side would do.


Manchester United v Aston Villa, Premier League, Old Trafford, 12.45pm, 29 March 2014

Possible Teams
United (4-4-1-1): De Gea; Rafael, Jones, Vidic, Buttner; Young, Fellaini, Fletcher, Kagawa; Mata; Rooney

Villa (4-5-1): Guzman; Lowton, Baker, Vlaar, Bertrand; Westwood, Delph, Albrighton; Agbonlahor, Benteke, Weimann

United: Lindegaard, Evra, Ferdinand, Giggs, Januzaj, Carrick, Hernandez, Welbeck

Villa: Steer, Clark, Luna, Bennett, Bacuna, Sylla, Tonev, Holt, Helenius

Head to Head
United 94 Draw 38 Villa 49

Match Officials
Referee: Martin Atkinson
Assistants: S Child, H Lennard
Fourth Official: C Pawson


Matchday Forum
Join the discussion here!


Mark - March 29, 2014 Reply

Is English David Moyes first language? Every time he speaks it’s just jibberish. Spouting out random statements with no real fact or evidence to back him up.
The fact he’s now saying SAF would have struggled just as he is this year is beyond belief. SAF proved over 20 years that United under him would not be in anywhere near the position they are now.
You Moyes, over your entire career have only ever proven to be a mid table manager at best, and surprise surprise, that’s where you have taken last years runaway Champions (plus 70mill more worth of talent!).
Coincidence? Is it also a coincidence that Everton are playing better than United and a much more attractive style of play this season? Where is their transitional period if you were so valuable to them?
Your ever constant supply of excuses is utterly pathetic and you are in no way worthy to be manager at MUFC. Just resign with atleast a smidge of dignity left and let the rebuilding process really begin. You will only take us further away from where we need to be.

Raphael C - March 29, 2014 Reply

There is a scene in The Dark Knight, where the Joker says,

“… In their last moments, people show you who they really are… would you like to know which of them were cowards?…”

Personally, Moyes’ comments lately have been far more depressing than any actual results.

In recent days, Brendan Rogers of Liverpool has come out saying he would never have called Liverpool underdogs at Anfield even if they were bottom of the table.

Jose Mourinho of Chelsea has come out asking how is it Sir Alex’s fault that the team is losing when he is retired and not in control of the team.

How is it rival managers are talking so much sense, when our own man is not?

red1961 - March 30, 2014 Reply

The only people who make the decision as to whether Moyes stays or goes are the Glazers
Because of the type of people they are the decision will be based purely on money.

I disagree that the plane stunt(even though it was a bit toy) had no impact.
The reptiles have a huge deal with Chevrolet and are negotiating a shirt deal of 70m + with Nike.
Do people think that Nike and Chevrolet will be pleased when they see an act like this being broadcast to billions?
Money and only money will be the deciding factor. Leopards do not change their spots
Moyes is a clueless clown but 10 out of 10 for balls today. Walking out before the team took some guts. Pity he doesn’t show more of it with ‘his tactics

Also there is an article in the Express stating that Giggs in on his way at the end of the season (playing and coaching) If that happens it is obvious that the support of even the most devote lemming will go with him.
In response to an earlier question next manager should be Van Gaal to be followed by somebody like Bielsa.
Managerial continuity is not linked to success in the modern game. Exception rather than the rule, look at Arsenal.

Add your comment